Sunday, March 30, 2014

Chapters 1-3 
Discussion Questions

1. The problem: "They rarely get below the surface to the richer, deeper meaning of the text. They think one reading is sufficient; they don't have the skills to uncover the craft, the complexities, and the nuances of the text" (3). The question: How to motivate those students who do not understand the complexities of even the most basic text?

2. The goal: "When we teach students to read deeply, we become more than information dispensers in our classrooms. We become cultivators of critical reading skills--skills of lifelong value" (10). The comment/question: how can we overcome a student's non-existent background knowledge to build a future that includes a desire for critical reading skills?

3. How can we apply the Model for Teaching Challenging Texts (page 12) to other areas of instruction? (Framing the Text => Read Carefully => Return to the Text => Collaboration => Metaphorical Response/Reflective Response) Is there a way to use this method of text presentation for our pre/post assessment/survey for students?

4. Section of Chapter 3: "Why Cold Reading is Often a Bad Idea": Quote: "My point is that reading comprehension is tied closely to what the reader brings to the page--what the reader knows before reading" (26). Questions: What if the student has NO prior knowledge with which to refer? And most importantly, if Common Core is here to stay, how can we adequately prepare students for a test which does not allow for students (most students, at least) to activate prior knowledge?!

5. The importance of the relevance quotation: "we need to be certain that today's curriculum contains connections to their past experiences, not just ours" (28). Sometimes as an English teacher, I wonder how often some of us tend to teach what WE love, rather than what our STUDENTS will love. Are texts really ageless, or are we forcing them to be ageless for the sake of the "classics"?

6. The question of the "novelty seeker" on page 30: I would love to be able to innovate and invent new ways to introduce students to the wonders of literature and nonfiction by providing them with a new "stimuli" that would "spark their brains to take notice;" however, how is this possible with all of the rigors of testing, data, and other areas that are time-consuming. I want the "unpredictability" that Gallagher describes, but...? (Any suggestions would be welcome!)

7. Word Scramble Prediction Activity (During Reading): page 49: Comment: I think that this would be a great activity that would represent itself well across the content areas. This could be done with articles and textbook chapters, as well as literature. 
Chapters 1-3 Discussion Questions

1.  I like the comments from Dale who says that the act of collaboration raises the reading comprehension of every student.  What strategies are other group members using to guide readers in a collaborative reading group?
2.  I like Gallagher's comments about using metaphors to deepen comprehension.   How are other group members using this strategy?  Would using visuals further to deepen comprehension?
3.  I like Gallagher's comments about giving students an opportunity to deepen their comprehension through second-draft reading. How are other members using this strategy?  Is it being used in Science, Tech, Global Studies, Math?

Ann Staiger Chapters 1-23 Deeper Reading: Thoughts and Discussion Points



Let me start by saying my first impression of this book is very positive.  I usually tend to get turned off by these how to books because they become repetitive or put in too many student examples (that are  questionable as to validity at times)

The points that I really liked and want to delve into more with my classes….

1.     1.    I really liked the baseball analogy to reading comprehension.  This is where I feel most of my students are.  They can tell you the basics but further questioning usually reveals a lack of real understanding.
2.      2.  I am going to use the Conversation piece with my 8th graders at some point this April. I will be curious as to why they will infer. I think it is a good way to show them  what they need to continually do as they read.
3.     3.   I have been working on providing more supports before students are doing their reading.  After reading this, I realize I can do even more- especially with making the connections to the relevance to them.
4.     4.   I definitely see the need for collaboration and am familiar with the percentage info on retaining info.  What I have found is that usually it needs to be a whole class discussion to make sure that everyone really understands the material.    I find short timed group work is best in social studies –especially with this age group- because they tend to veer off into other areas of interest pretty quickly.
5.     5.   The metaphors process (which I thought was great) would probably work best comparing  events in history versus a vocabulary word.  I will be trying that for our WWII unit since at this point they all should have some good background knowledge to draw on from past conflicts.
6.       6. Developing self-sufficient readers has always been a challenge when using the textbook.   We’ve been learning about the Great Depression this month.  Even with a fairly comprehensive overview before they do the reading, I’ve found that maybe not more than one quarter of the students are really able to find the info and answer the question posed when done independently.
7.       7. Getting students involved with the learning process means making it relevant to them. I realize that the KWLR charts are something I need to do.  I did a few over the years but then just stopped.   It draws them in and I could use the post reading research as extra credit.    I will be using that this coming week to help me determine what they want to learn about and should tell me what are some areas that need more review /explanation on my part.
8.      8.  The daily focus question on  the board and interrupted summary would serve as a re-enforcement of the key idea that they should have come away with  in prior lessons
9.      9.  I liked the idea of making the classroom experience unpredictable- it doesn’t become the same old same old.  With that said, it also takes some significant time to keep things fresh and find worthwhile activities that still address the learning needs.
1
Discussion questions
1.        1. What are some strategies group members use now to prepare their students before reading?
2.       2. Assigning groups can be challenging yet collaboration is a key ingredient to developing understanding as written here.   Suggestions for what makes for positive meaningful collaborative groups?
       3. I was surprised that in many of his examples his students had little or no knowledge of historical events that they most definitely would have had instruction in their social studies /history classes.  Another example of little transference between classes and subjects? Thoughts?
3.       4. Are English teachers now being expected to know more about history in order to prep their students before taking on many novels (setting the stage etc)?  Will that create another challenge?
4.        

T   The strategies he uses appear to be far different than what the Common Core directions are for students when they do close reading. I copied what is below directly from Engage NY -Long Night of the Little Boats  G8

Introduce the text and students read independently.Other than giving the brief definitions offered to words students would likely not beable to define from context (underlined in the text), avoid giving any background context or instructional guidance at the outset of the lesson while students are reading the text silently. This close reading approach  forces students to rely exclusively on the text, and levels the playing field for all students as they seek to comprehend Heatter’s text. It is critical to cultivating independence and creating a culture of close reading that students initially grapple with rich texts like Heatter’s prose without the aid of prefatory material, extensive notes, or even teacher explanations.



Ch 1-3 Discussion Question:

Here are my discussion question ideas:

1) In the author's words, reading is like baseball. Can we each come up with our own metaphors to explain what reading is?

2) I will repost the author's main question, because I think it should be our question of focus: "What can we do, as teachers, to prepare our students to read challenging text at the deepest levels possible?"

3) I like his arguments about second-draft reading, but does anyone feel this is a hurdle because of motivational issues to read something twice?

4) I like his concept of using metaphorical language to explain things. This obviously applies to an English class, but what are some metaphors we might use in Social Studies, Tech, or Science to explain a concept or passage?

5) How do we answer students in our classes when they ask about relevance?

6) I like his comment that we need to "make our classroom experience as varied as possible. This is a call for unpredictability." I know I can see when a lack of this happens in my room because I lose students. Thoughts? How do we still maintain this "variation" when our classroom control is becoming more and more narrow?

7) Does anyone have examples THEY use that are similar to his focusing activities in Chapter 3? There are several that are similar to ones I use, and I think we could learn a lot from each other if we shared strategies.

8) How do we make the content of this book more applicable to other subject areas that use little or no fiction?


Thursday, March 20, 2014

Assignments for the Book Study:

Meeting #2 --- March 31 --- Read Chapters 1-3 and post 5-10 discussion questions before the meeting.
   (Leader: Meredith)

Meeting #3 --- April 7 --- Read Chapters 4-6 and post 5-10 discussion questions before the meeting.
   (Leader: Kelly)

Meeting #4 --- April 21 --- Read Chapters 7-10 and post 5-10 discussion questions before the meeting.
   (Leader: Ann)

**Remember to check this blog before each meeting to prepare for the discussion points.

Wednesday, March 19, 2014

I just finished a biography of Harper Lee, "Mockingbird".  She has a haunted mix of empathy, brilliance and unhappiness.  Not unhappy because of the other two, but apparently from some deeper flaws...  She's an object lesson for me.  JZ

Tuesday, March 18, 2014

Action Plan

Meeting: 3.7.14, 2:30-4:00 p.m.

Participants: Dawn Larson (facilitator), John Benjamin, Meredith Roessner, Ann Staiger, Kelly Tongate

ACTION PLAN

Project Title: Deeper Reading & Strategies for Success

Study Group Goal or Purpose:
·         Our purpose is to learn more about deep reading, to define what deep reading is, to discuss and collaborate with colleagues across disciplines, and to provide students with the tools for success when approaching difficult and complex texts within the classroom through scaffolded implementation.

·         Topics to be included are:
o   Preparing our students and scaffolding instruction
o   Teaching challenging texts
o   Focusing the reader
o   Effective first-draft reading
o   Teaching context in the classroom
o   Deepening comprehension through second-draft reading
o   The importance of collaboration
o   Using metaphor to deepen comprehension
o   Leading students to meaningful reflection
o   The art of teaching deeper reading
o   Strategies to monitor comprehension of complex texts
o   Also, any other topics that are introduced through peer collaboration and discussion throughout the meetings and reflection

·         Include a description of student needs addressed by this proposal:
o   Comprehension of complex texts
o   Immersion in a variety of more difficult texts
o   Useful strategies to aid in comprehension, as well as strategies to help in confusion

  • The role of each group member, listing the specific activities of each group member.
    • Recorder: Record notes during meetings, including important questions that arise and reflections upon the teaching of deep reading.
    • Facilitator: Prepares to direct the meeting, by reviewing the blog posts from each participant and introducing further questions to initiate discussion.
    • Blog Manager: Posts meeting notes to blog for review by other participants, as well as colleagues throughout the school district.
    • Secretary: Keeps records of the meeting notes, sign-in log, and itineraries of the meetings in order.
    • Every Participant: Prepare 5-10 discussion questions, important quotations from the reading, disagreements, reflections, or points for discussion on the blog before each meeting. Participants will check the blog regularly, especially before the next date of the meeting.
      • Roles of group members will change for each meeting, allowing each member to be responsible for a different aspect of the meetings.

·         How will you proceed to accomplish your purpose or goal?

o   Meet and discuss important ideas and practices presented in the text.
o   Discuss and post questions on the blog to share with colleagues.
o   Present findings in a workshop to colleagues to help further the use of deep reading across the disciplines.

·         What will your measurable outcomes be?
o   Discussion points within each meeting, and in preparation for each meeting.
o   Student survey: before implementation, and after implementation of deep reading strategies.
o   Assessment of student achievement after implementation of deep reading strategies.
o   Blog discussions and important questions that arise in the discourse of the book study.

·         What evidence will indicate that your intended purpose or goal has been attained?  Include descriptions of the formative and summative assessment that will be used to evaluate the impact the work of the study group will have/has on student achievement.
o   Success of classroom implementation.
o   Formative and Summative assessment will be further expanded upon once the desired text is obtained.

·         How will your evaluate the success of this project? (Evaluation) Please include samples of evaluations you will use and describe any statistical data you hope to collect.
o   Student survey at the beginning of the research process, implementation of tools for student success, and the survey at the end of the research process.
o   Reflection by the participants of the book study.

·         How will you share your work with your colleagues (In addition to the blog)?
o   Blog.
o   Mini workshop for interested colleagues in strategies to implement in aided student success with complex and diverse texts.

·         Identify the resources (print and non-print) that will be used by the group members.
o   Deeper Reading by Kelly Gallagher
o   Student surveys (prior to implementation of strategies)
o   Strategies to implement in the classroom
o   Student surveys (after the implementation of strategies)
o   Student reflection on the effectiveness of the strategies implemented