Evidence of Teaching Practices
I tested my seventh grade students on a passage in the social studies book that they had no background on. It gave me a better understanding of how they read text and internalize questions. I have taken more time in the beginning of the class to set the stage. I have used some primary sources more to begin the lessons. KWLR charts were used and I've linked the political cartoon site recommended onto my teacher's blog for students to access. We watch CNN Student News to ensure students are getting info on what's happening here and around the world, so I will try to find cartoons that relate to what they have watched in past weeks. There are other ideas that I plan to incorporate as well. While the book is definitely geared more to literature instruction, there were many simple ideas that I will use to further involve students in the concept of how it impacts them.
Evidence of Student Achievement
Students have begun the unit on WWII. The English teacher and I have consulted a bit on making sure that we are covering the main basics of the Holocaust (Anne Frank Diary play). The students are filling out the KWLR chart, and many have indicated they have done some outside research already on topics that we have touched on briefly in class. I did a lesson on Pearl Harbor and we discussed some of the statistics and general facts prior to watching and listening to the primary sources and photos from the attack. The D Day lesson included a short film prior to reading a short excerpt from the text, clarifying some vocabulary and info, and then reading Eisenhower's speech to the men prior to the land invasion. They had to use the speech to identify character traits for Eisenhower and infer why he chose some of the specific wording that day. I finished the lesson with students having to read and answer questions that showed the physical locations of the five beach landings using a map from the period.
Evidence of Goals Met
We had a very short window to complete our book study, yet everyone was able to meet each of the deadlines and post their discussion comments. In addition, based on our conversations all the teachers felt that we got a great deal from the book and would highly recommend it to others. I have implemented some of the "easier" ideas already, and plan to use summer curriculum time to go through more of the ideas and adapt them for my classroom Once these are done, I will be choosing the top five and sharing them with the social studies department members. Some of this evidence will evolve over time and I will continue to seek out ways to bring out students' creativity and ideas which will help them with the curriculum.
I cannot attach them so have sent hard copies to our facilitator for the group.
In conclusion, I felt the book was a worthwhile read and provided a lot of food for thought. As I said in our group, I've found many of these types of books to include lots of filler of student stories but this one stayed focused on strategies. I am excited to go back and identify some key ones that would work with social studies. Each member contributed ideas and showed me how each of us faces challenges on an on-going basis. It takes time, dedication, and a commitment to teaching to provide students with positive learning experiences. Trying new things keeps things fresh for students and teachers alike.
Wednesday, April 30, 2014
Study Group Final Report: Larson: English 8
Study Group Final
Report:
Larson
English 8
Study Group Final Report Outline
Project Title: Deeper Reading & Strategies for
Success
Study Group Goal or Purpose:
*Our purpose is to learn more about deep reading, to define
what deep reading is, to discuss and collaborate with colleagues across
disciplines, and to provide students with the tools for success when
approaching difficult and complex texts within the classroom through scaffolded
implementation.
- This goal
and purpose was successfully met, without any alterations.
Implementation of Action Plan:
How will you proceed to accomplish your purpose or goal?
o Meet and discuss
important ideas and practices presented in the text. þ
o Discuss and post
questions on the blog to share with colleagues. þ
o Present findings
in a workshop to colleagues to help further the use of deep reading across the
disciplines.
*Altered:
Individual participants will present findings and useful strategies to their
individual departments at a future
department meeting.
What will your measurable outcomes be?
o Discussion points
within each meeting, and in preparation for each meeting. þ
o Student survey:
before implementation, and after implementation of deep reading strategies.
* Altered:
Students were given a pre-assessment (without any strategies or background knowledge) and a post-assessment
(with strategies and background knowledge) to gauge learning.
o Assessment of
student achievement after implementation of deep reading strategies. þ
o Blog discussions
and important questions that arise in the discourse of the book study. þ
Evidence of Teaching Practices
As an English teacher, this book was an amazing resource and
reference to add to my teaching collection. The ideas and strategies presented
by Gallagher were easily transferable to the classroom, and to a variety of
central pieces of literature I use. After our 4 week study of this book, I was
able to implement many strategies to help my students read and comprehend what
they read with greater ease and practice. Some of the strategies I implemented
in my classroom included: The Word Game (47), Interrupted Summary (48), Word
Scramble Prediction (49), Character Charts (60), Collaboration Roles (127), and
assorted Metaphorical Graphic Organizers (135-144). Activities my students
seemed to enjoy were The Word Game, Word Scramble Prediction, and Metaphorical
Sentence Fill-in-the-Blanks (143).
Evidence of Student Achievement
Pre-Assessment: I did not give students any
background knowledge or offer any assistance on reading the poem “Holocaust,”
as an introductory activity to the unit The Diary of Anne Frank Play.
Instead, students were asked to read and evaluate ten questions about their
reading of the poem. Students, in general, struggled to understand the context,
which made answering the questions difficult. Some had trouble with identifying
the term the poem was about (Holocaust), since they didn’t know what that word
meant.
Post-Assessment: Students were asked to refer back to
the same poem from the Pre-Assessment, after reading the play for the unit. The
unit is comprised of reading different texts about World War 2, as well as
researching a component of the time period (i.e. concentration camps, Hitler
Youth movement, the Pacific warfront, etc.). After being immersed in the time
period, and being more familiar with the vocabulary, students were able to
approach this poem, the second time, with clarity, and insight.
Further pieces of evidence: Students completed a few
ticket in responses, asking them to respond to a quote or word from the
previous lesson. Students were then asked to explain the importance of the
quote or term (i.e. The Star of David) to the play we’ve read so far. Also,
students completed a Word Scramble Prediction, using a list of words from an
upcoming scene, to predict what they think the next scene would be about.
Students were incredibly insightful, and when we read the scene, had “ah-ha”
moments of recognition that showed they connected with the prediction activity,
and were excited to discover parts of their predictions were accurate.
*Attached: Ticket In Examples, Word Scramble
Prediction, and Pre/Post Assessment (“Holocaust” Poem)
Evidence of Goals Met
-The group met and
discussed deeper reading strategies with a specific focus on helping students
better approach a difficult text without confusion.
*Attached:
4.11.14
TICKET IN
THE STAR OF DAVID
Explain the significance
(importance) of those
words to the reading from
yesterday (Act I, Sc 2).
4.22.14
TICKET IN
Act I, Scene 3 (page 721)
Anne:
Things have changed. People aren’t like that any more. “Yes, Mother.” “No,
Mother.” “Anything you say, Mother.” I’ve got to fight things out for myself!
Make something of myself!
Why is this quote important to the
reading we did before break?
What does this tell us about Anne?
Word Scramble Prediction
Act I, Scene 5
Take a few minutes to write a prediction of what
will happen in
this scene, based on the following words taken from
Scene 5.
Include WHY you think this prediction will be
accurate!
(3-5 sentences)

Pre/Post Assessment:
Holocaust
by Sudeep Pagedar - Selected Poems
How do you
explain that term
to a ten-
year old boy
who, one day,
hears it mentioned
by some relatives?
And even if
you do manage
to make him
understand what it
actually does mean,
do you also
tell him that
because he is
A GERMAN JEW,
perhaps, some day,
he might be
included in it...?
Or should he
just not be
told, so that
he remains calm
and doesn't lose
sleep over it?
But what is sleep,
in front of death?
Perhaps Death is greater,
perhaps the two are the same;
we do not know yet
but we'll know, by the end of the day;
the Chambers are yet some hours away.
"To die, to sleep...to sleep, perchance to dream..."
How did Shakespeare realise that?
Did he know some Jew
who was persecuted too?
Perhaps he was wrong,
maybe he was right...
Anyway, I suspect we'll find out
by tonight.
by Sudeep Pagedar - Selected Poems
How do you
explain that term
to a ten-
year old boy
who, one day,
hears it mentioned
by some relatives?
And even if
you do manage
to make him
understand what it
actually does mean,
do you also
tell him that
because he is
A GERMAN JEW,
perhaps, some day,
he might be
included in it...?
Or should he
just not be
told, so that
he remains calm
and doesn't lose
sleep over it?
But what is sleep,
in front of death?
Perhaps Death is greater,
perhaps the two are the same;
we do not know yet
but we'll know, by the end of the day;
the Chambers are yet some hours away.
"To die, to sleep...to sleep, perchance to dream..."
How did Shakespeare realise that?
Did he know some Jew
who was persecuted too?
Perhaps he was wrong,
maybe he was right...
Anyway, I suspect we'll find out
by tonight.
Source: http://www.auschwitz.dk/id6.htm
Direction: Answer the following
questions after reading the poem, “Holocaust” by Sudeep
Pagedar.
1. Explain the central idea of the poem.
2. What term is the speaker trying to explain in line 2? Why?
3. Why does the author capitalize the line “A GERMAN JEW” in
line 16? What is the purpose of this?
4. What does the author mean by “someday, he might be
included in it…?” (lines 17-19)
5. What decision does the speaker need to make in this poem?
6. Analyze the use of the word “sleep” in this poem.
7. How do the multiple meanings of the word “sleep” affect
the poem’s tone?
8. Who wrote the quote, “to die, to sleep…to sleep, perchance
to dream…” (line 33)?
9. Based on the reading, what does the word “persecuted” mean
in line 36?
10. What will the speaker discover “tonight” in line 40
Study Group Final Report: Roessner English 10/12
Quick note: I couldn't attach my assignments as I wanted to because there was no link to attach Word documents to this blog. I have hard copies.
Evidence of Teaching Practices
This book was truly invaluable for an English teacher. In
addition to all the templates and class activities I plan on using, the author
did so much as to mention specific ideas using literature I already teach!
During our 4 week reading of this book, I was able to employ several classroom
strategies, including Word Game (47), Character Charts (60), Sentence Starters
(70), Responsibility Pie Charts (102), Ingredients Listing (136), and other
Metaphorical Graphic Organizers (143-144). Most notable were the Ingredients
Listing and Metaphorical Sentence Fill-in-the-Blanks (143). On the attached worksheet, you will see the
handout we completed using these two strategies to wrap-up “Death of a
Salesman.” Not only did my students enjoy the activity because it is framed
like a little game, but I truly feel that their understanding of the play and
the character deepened as a result. (See
Evidence of Achievement below for sample answers students submitted.)
Evidence of Student Achievement
My first pieces of evidence are my
pre/post assessments. (Both are
attached.) I used two different John Donne poems:
Ø
Pre-assessment: I activated no background
knowledge and did not preface the assignment with any connections, attention
grabbers, or class activities. Students did not understand my questions, did
not grasp metaphorical language, needed help with archaic words, and generally
got very frustrated. I even had a few of them say, “This is why I hate poetry.”
The only question they were able to successfully answer was about the rhyme
scheme, because they already knew how to identify this.
Ø
Post-Assessment: We spent almost an entire
period discussing John Donne’s life, his career, his religious knowledge and
beliefs, his family, etc. THEN I handed out the poem with the questions. I
still did not offer help and let them work together, but this time the answers
I got were far more successful. Students understood references the poet made to
his own life and his religion, they grasped metaphorical meanings, and they understood
WHY the poet wrote the poem. As a class, they generally liked the poem because
they understood it.
My second piece of evidence is the
assignment we completed in class using some of the author’s metaphorical
strategies from Chapter 7. (Please see
attached worksheet.) Students enjoyed the “game” quality to this and really
understood the character. Here are examples from the Metaphorical Sentence
Fill-in-the-Blank:
Ø
Willy Loman is like a llama because anytime
someone gets close to him, he pushes them away by spitting in their face.
Ø
Willy Loman is like a child because he
will do anything to get attention and won’t take the blame for anything.
Ø
The chain of events in this play is like a game
of Jenga because the foundation blocks of the family are crumbling
because of Willy’s pride.
Ø
The chain of events in this play is like the
weather in NY because every five minutes it changes.
Evidence of Goals Met
Ø
We completed the book in a timely manner
Ø
All of us truly got a lot out of our
professional conversations and the blog. It really helped to hear how other
teachers used these strategies already or came up with inventive ways to add
them to the curriculum.
Ø
I tried several classroom strategies outlined in
the book with success
Ø
I administered my pre and post assessments,
which CLEARLY indicated the importance of properly framing and introducing text
and connecting to background knowledge.
Ø
I have many new ideas to add to several units
and the curriculum as a whole
Ø
The book reworked and challenged my thinking/understanding
about reading comprehension
Tuesday, April 29, 2014
1.
What
evidence suggests that teaching practices have changed?
After
reading Deeper Reading by Kelly Gallagher, I have implemented strategies
from his book into my practice. I am
using focus questions and short videos to provide background knowledge prior to
reading text. Also, I am using the strategy of reading assessment questions to
students prior to reading text. I will be using additional strategies from the
Gallagher’s book in my planning.
2.
What
evidence suggests that student achievement is improving? Provide data and/or
artifacts.
Students were given a pre-assessment which
consisted of a non-fiction reading and five questions. These questions assessed author’s purpose,
mood, locating information within text, and two inference questions. The majority of the students were able to
answer the questions about author’s purpose and locating information within
text. Some students were able to answer
questions related to mood. The majority of the students had difficulty with the
inference questions.
After using a focus question and videos
to provide background knowledge, students were given a post-assessment which
consisted of a non-fiction reading and four questions. These questions required students to explain
a theory, identify main idea, use diagrams to explain concept and identify
author’s purpose. Questions were read to student before the text was read.
Students had success answering these questions when provided with the strategies mentioned.
3.
What
evidence suggests that the goals of the study group has/has not been met?
We met as a group for 3 meetings. Group
members read the book, Deeper Reading by Kelly Gallagher. Throughout the
reading of the book, members posted on a blog comments/questions to use as
points of discussion during weekly meetings. Group members completed a pre-assessment, selected strategies from the book to use in their classroom
and completed a post-assessment. This
information was presented at weekly meetings. Group members will share five
strategies with members of their department.
Monday, April 28, 2014
Ch 7-10
Kelly Tongate
Using Metaphor to Deepen Comprehension
Two benefits which sharpen higher level thinking:
1) Reach deeper comprehension of difficult text
2) Students can generate their own metaphorical connections to text and
life
Teaching of metaphors – help cultivate “imaginative
rationality” - three values:
1) Metaphors enliven ordinary language
2) Metaphors require interpretation – hard for kids – they need practice
3) Metaphors create new meanings – analyze both seen and UNSEEN
characteristics of people in books – compare to part of an iceberg floating above the surface
Metaphorical Graphic Organizers (for Characters):
1) Square Peg, Round Hole – expectations of character (round hole) and
character’s needs (square peg)
-
character goes against time or place
-
conflict – between what character wants
and what character “should” do
2) Brake Pedal, Accelerator Pedal
-
force (people, place, thing) that slows
the character and force that accelerates the character’s thinking or behavior
-
character resists others or gets swept up
in other’s actions
-
“braking” actions of a character may be a
positive force
3) Ingredients listing
-
most important character traits listed
first
-
helps with complex characters
-
what would happen if you add or delete
one ingredient
4) Archery Target
-
character goals – is character close to
reaching goal(s)
-
works with novels where characters have
goals
-
list goals
5)
Wallet/Purse
-
items in “wallet/purse” of character -
analyze
-
works in any novel
-
infer: “What would be in his locker,
etc.”
Metaphorical Graphic Organizers (for
Plot and Structure):
1) Pencil/Eraser
-
character name on pencil: - eraser - actions character wants to erase
- lead – actions character wishes he had done
- works with any novel
- how to erase actions
2) Proof Sheets
- analyze only and exactly 24 key plot
points (“pictures”) and why they are
important (vs. other points)
-
works with complex novels
-
which 4 “pictures” highlight the book
3)
Billiards Table
-
which characters represent the cue ball,
the eight ball, the target ball, the bumper, the cue, etc.
-
works well with “chain of events” novels
-
what character “scratched” à
what were the chain of events leading to the “scratch”
Metaphorical Graphic Organizers (Setting):
1)
Snow Globe
-
what would be inside to capture the
essence of the novel
-
works well when setting plays a key role
-
rank settings in the novel and defend
2)
Time Capsule
-
put in things which give the reader a
sense of time and place
-
works well when setting is the key
-
rank most to least important and defend
3)
Backdrop, Props
-
three or four backdrops for sense of
setting
-
works well where setting is key
-
what props would you add to the novel
Five Considerations
(moving from familiar to new):
1)
Use metaphors to interpret metaphors
2)
Don’t
turn graphic organizers into worksheets – have students draw their own (i.e. –
brake and accelerator and then have them fill it in) ß
to increase motivation
3)
“Newness Factor” – thinking metaphorically
helps develop the ability to improvise different metaphorically graphic
organizers
4)
Students create and draw their own
metaphorical graphic organizers – give them starter sentences (pages 143-144)
5)
Use metaphorical graphic organizers as a
springboard to writing
Meaningful
Reflection
- There are endless
reasons to read
- As teachers we must
help students discover the book’s greatness by developing
appropriate lessons
-
Models help students write better
-
Critical questions which must be
answered:
1)
What does the book mean to us today?
2)
Why did we read this book?
********Critical
Question: “What do I hope my students will take from this book?”***********
-Levels of Reflection:
self à
family à
peers à
community à
country à
humankind
******- Reflection is
one of the most important reasons for reading-************
Strategies to Encourage
Reflection:
1)
Three Degrees of … (evil, compassion,
oppression, sacrifice, greed, love, or any central idea)
2)
The Most Valuable Idea (from novel) –
chart (page 160)
3)
Theme Notebooks – relate themes to today
4)
Casting Call – real people take
character’s roles in the novel – can be anyone (ie – George Bush, your uncle,
etc.) and why that person (connect to the real world)
5)
Theme Layers – connecting the theme to
the real world
6)
Anchor Questions – to consider while
reading – they provide a focus
7)
Author’s purpose
Reading the World
1)
“Loaded” Language
-
Euphemisms – mild/indirect expression
rather than the harsh/unpleasant one
-
Saying one thing and meaning another
2)
Cradle- to-Grave Consumerism
-
Let’s Eat! – deception à
manipulation
-
Talk is not Cheap à
deceptive phone ads
-
“Spam” is a Four Letter Word –
advertising frontier
3)
Read All About It – newspaper
understanding
-
Wacky World – expose kids to crazy
stories in newspapers
-
Scavenger Hunt – of the newspaper
-
Newspaper Reading Minute – to encourage
newspaper reading
4)
Deeper Newspaper Reading
-
Just the Facts – very biased – “yellow
journalism”
-
Weekly Reflection of Newspaper
5) Reading Political Cartoons – look at:
-
subject, context, purpose, audience,
thesis, what is NOT said
6)
Interpreting
Statistics
FUNNY à - Three kinds of lies – lies,
damned lies, statistics ß
FUNNY
***********************
If
we don’t, then who will? **********************
-
Are students adequately prepared ?
-
If they are not prepared, then what will
happen to them?
-
What is more important in 10 years –
“Gatsby” or making sense of a ballot initiative
The Art of Teaching
Deep Reading
4 Key Questions when
planning deeper reading lessons:
1)
Without teacher assistance, what will the students take from the reading?
2)
With assistance, what do I want the kids to take from the reading?
3) How
do I bridge the gap between what the kids learn on their own and what I want
them to learn?
4) How do I know if they “got
it”?
EXCELLENT à
AIDS example ß
***********Assessments
should drive the teaching****************
(Backward design)
– students should know “final exam” question
before reading novel
Danger Lurks! :
1) Over teaching the book
2) Student becomes over reliant on the teacher
Begin the year with
lots of help and reduce teacher role in the process gradually so the student is
using strategies more independently
Sunday, April 27, 2014
Chapters 7-10
Notes/Discussion Points
Larson
Chapter 7: Metaphors
"The only way to help students develop this higher level thinking is to provide them with opportunities to practice interpretive thinking." (129)
The Iceberg Metaphor/Graphic Organizer: Applicable to other courses of study?
I really love some of the graphic organizers with metaphors: Square Peg-Round Hole (135), Proof Sheets (137), and the idea of having students creating their own metaphorical graphic organizers with the sentence starters (143): (Character name) is like a because . Then, students create their own graphic organizers.
The big idea: metaphor and the use of graphically representing them as a springboard for WRITING (144).
(Big point: the correlation between increased writing and excelling on reading comprehension assessments is a great connection here.)
Like the idea of using a metaphorical graphic organizer to spring into a writing exercise or essay.
Chapter 8: Meaningful Reflection
One quote that stuck out: "Their aversion to reading is appalling" (151).
Points that Gallagher made that I liked:
*I must reconsider MY approach, when students find a great book boring
*Make the author's craft visible
Loved the use of the persuasive essay ("My Turn"--Newsweek) as a model of how to write a good persuasive essay (153).
How is the book we are reading relevant to THEIR lives? Circle of reflection, Powell (153).
"It is always my goal to push their thinking beyond personal implications and toward larger connections" which is what I think the goal of learning/loving great literature is... (158).
Strategies to encourage reflection that I appreciated: Three degrees of..., Most Valuable Idea (chart), Theme Layers, Anchor Questions, and The Hunt for the Author's Purpose.
Chapter 9: Reading the World
"Developing the ability to read and pass a test is desirable; developing the ability to read the world is even more important" (168).
Freire: "The world is a difficult text" (169).
Interesting activities and points Gallagher makes: Loaded Language, Weasel Words, Propaganda, Newspaper Knowledge/Integration.
Chapter 10
Backwards planning: great illustration of the reason for planning this way.
What you test is what you get (211).
Final notes: I think that these ideas would be GREAT to spread out throughout the year, but trying to fit more than 2 into a small unit, or 5 into a normal sized unit would be pushing it. What would be the best way to approach getting enough strategies without overdoing it?
Larson
Chapter 7: Metaphors
"The only way to help students develop this higher level thinking is to provide them with opportunities to practice interpretive thinking." (129)
The Iceberg Metaphor/Graphic Organizer: Applicable to other courses of study?
I really love some of the graphic organizers with metaphors: Square Peg-Round Hole (135), Proof Sheets (137), and the idea of having students creating their own metaphorical graphic organizers with the sentence starters (143): (Character name) is like a because . Then, students create their own graphic organizers.
The big idea: metaphor and the use of graphically representing them as a springboard for WRITING (144).
(Big point: the correlation between increased writing and excelling on reading comprehension assessments is a great connection here.)
Like the idea of using a metaphorical graphic organizer to spring into a writing exercise or essay.
Chapter 8: Meaningful Reflection
One quote that stuck out: "Their aversion to reading is appalling" (151).
Points that Gallagher made that I liked:
*I must reconsider MY approach, when students find a great book boring
*Make the author's craft visible
Loved the use of the persuasive essay ("My Turn"--Newsweek) as a model of how to write a good persuasive essay (153).
How is the book we are reading relevant to THEIR lives? Circle of reflection, Powell (153).
"It is always my goal to push their thinking beyond personal implications and toward larger connections" which is what I think the goal of learning/loving great literature is... (158).
Strategies to encourage reflection that I appreciated: Three degrees of..., Most Valuable Idea (chart), Theme Layers, Anchor Questions, and The Hunt for the Author's Purpose.
Chapter 9: Reading the World
"Developing the ability to read and pass a test is desirable; developing the ability to read the world is even more important" (168).
Freire: "The world is a difficult text" (169).
Interesting activities and points Gallagher makes: Loaded Language, Weasel Words, Propaganda, Newspaper Knowledge/Integration.
Chapter 10
Backwards planning: great illustration of the reason for planning this way.
What you test is what you get (211).
Final notes: I think that these ideas would be GREAT to spread out throughout the year, but trying to fit more than 2 into a small unit, or 5 into a normal sized unit would be pushing it. What would be the best way to approach getting enough strategies without overdoing it?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)