Sunday, March 30, 2014

Chapters 1-3 
Discussion Questions

1. The problem: "They rarely get below the surface to the richer, deeper meaning of the text. They think one reading is sufficient; they don't have the skills to uncover the craft, the complexities, and the nuances of the text" (3). The question: How to motivate those students who do not understand the complexities of even the most basic text?

2. The goal: "When we teach students to read deeply, we become more than information dispensers in our classrooms. We become cultivators of critical reading skills--skills of lifelong value" (10). The comment/question: how can we overcome a student's non-existent background knowledge to build a future that includes a desire for critical reading skills?

3. How can we apply the Model for Teaching Challenging Texts (page 12) to other areas of instruction? (Framing the Text => Read Carefully => Return to the Text => Collaboration => Metaphorical Response/Reflective Response) Is there a way to use this method of text presentation for our pre/post assessment/survey for students?

4. Section of Chapter 3: "Why Cold Reading is Often a Bad Idea": Quote: "My point is that reading comprehension is tied closely to what the reader brings to the page--what the reader knows before reading" (26). Questions: What if the student has NO prior knowledge with which to refer? And most importantly, if Common Core is here to stay, how can we adequately prepare students for a test which does not allow for students (most students, at least) to activate prior knowledge?!

5. The importance of the relevance quotation: "we need to be certain that today's curriculum contains connections to their past experiences, not just ours" (28). Sometimes as an English teacher, I wonder how often some of us tend to teach what WE love, rather than what our STUDENTS will love. Are texts really ageless, or are we forcing them to be ageless for the sake of the "classics"?

6. The question of the "novelty seeker" on page 30: I would love to be able to innovate and invent new ways to introduce students to the wonders of literature and nonfiction by providing them with a new "stimuli" that would "spark their brains to take notice;" however, how is this possible with all of the rigors of testing, data, and other areas that are time-consuming. I want the "unpredictability" that Gallagher describes, but...? (Any suggestions would be welcome!)

7. Word Scramble Prediction Activity (During Reading): page 49: Comment: I think that this would be a great activity that would represent itself well across the content areas. This could be done with articles and textbook chapters, as well as literature. 

No comments:

Post a Comment

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.