Kelly Tongate
Using Metaphor to Deepen Comprehension
Two benefits which sharpen higher level thinking:
1) Reach deeper comprehension of difficult text
2) Students can generate their own metaphorical connections to text and
life
Teaching of metaphors – help cultivate “imaginative
rationality” - three values:
1) Metaphors enliven ordinary language
2) Metaphors require interpretation – hard for kids – they need practice
3) Metaphors create new meanings – analyze both seen and UNSEEN
characteristics of people in books – compare to part of an iceberg floating above the surface
Metaphorical Graphic Organizers (for Characters):
1) Square Peg, Round Hole – expectations of character (round hole) and
character’s needs (square peg)
-
character goes against time or place
-
conflict – between what character wants
and what character “should” do
2) Brake Pedal, Accelerator Pedal
-
force (people, place, thing) that slows
the character and force that accelerates the character’s thinking or behavior
-
character resists others or gets swept up
in other’s actions
-
“braking” actions of a character may be a
positive force
3) Ingredients listing
-
most important character traits listed
first
-
helps with complex characters
-
what would happen if you add or delete
one ingredient
4) Archery Target
-
character goals – is character close to
reaching goal(s)
-
works with novels where characters have
goals
-
list goals
5)
Wallet/Purse
-
items in “wallet/purse” of character -
analyze
-
works in any novel
-
infer: “What would be in his locker,
etc.”
Metaphorical Graphic Organizers (for
Plot and Structure):
1) Pencil/Eraser
-
character name on pencil: - eraser - actions character wants to erase
- lead – actions character wishes he had done
- works with any novel
- how to erase actions
2) Proof Sheets
- analyze only and exactly 24 key plot
points (“pictures”) and why they are
important (vs. other points)
-
works with complex novels
-
which 4 “pictures” highlight the book
3)
Billiards Table
-
which characters represent the cue ball,
the eight ball, the target ball, the bumper, the cue, etc.
-
works well with “chain of events” novels
-
what character “scratched” à
what were the chain of events leading to the “scratch”
Metaphorical Graphic Organizers (Setting):
1)
Snow Globe
-
what would be inside to capture the
essence of the novel
-
works well when setting plays a key role
-
rank settings in the novel and defend
2)
Time Capsule
-
put in things which give the reader a
sense of time and place
-
works well when setting is the key
-
rank most to least important and defend
3)
Backdrop, Props
-
three or four backdrops for sense of
setting
-
works well where setting is key
-
what props would you add to the novel
Five Considerations
(moving from familiar to new):
1)
Use metaphors to interpret metaphors
2)
Don’t
turn graphic organizers into worksheets – have students draw their own (i.e. –
brake and accelerator and then have them fill it in) ß
to increase motivation
3)
“Newness Factor” – thinking metaphorically
helps develop the ability to improvise different metaphorically graphic
organizers
4)
Students create and draw their own
metaphorical graphic organizers – give them starter sentences (pages 143-144)
5)
Use metaphorical graphic organizers as a
springboard to writing
Meaningful
Reflection
- There are endless
reasons to read
- As teachers we must
help students discover the book’s greatness by developing
appropriate lessons
-
Models help students write better
-
Critical questions which must be
answered:
1)
What does the book mean to us today?
2)
Why did we read this book?
********Critical
Question: “What do I hope my students will take from this book?”***********
-Levels of Reflection:
self à
family à
peers à
community à
country à
humankind
******- Reflection is
one of the most important reasons for reading-************
Strategies to Encourage
Reflection:
1)
Three Degrees of … (evil, compassion,
oppression, sacrifice, greed, love, or any central idea)
2)
The Most Valuable Idea (from novel) –
chart (page 160)
3)
Theme Notebooks – relate themes to today
4)
Casting Call – real people take
character’s roles in the novel – can be anyone (ie – George Bush, your uncle,
etc.) and why that person (connect to the real world)
5)
Theme Layers – connecting the theme to
the real world
6)
Anchor Questions – to consider while
reading – they provide a focus
7)
Author’s purpose
Reading the World
1)
“Loaded” Language
-
Euphemisms – mild/indirect expression
rather than the harsh/unpleasant one
-
Saying one thing and meaning another
2)
Cradle- to-Grave Consumerism
-
Let’s Eat! – deception à
manipulation
-
Talk is not Cheap à
deceptive phone ads
-
“Spam” is a Four Letter Word –
advertising frontier
3)
Read All About It – newspaper
understanding
-
Wacky World – expose kids to crazy
stories in newspapers
-
Scavenger Hunt – of the newspaper
-
Newspaper Reading Minute – to encourage
newspaper reading
4)
Deeper Newspaper Reading
-
Just the Facts – very biased – “yellow
journalism”
-
Weekly Reflection of Newspaper
5) Reading Political Cartoons – look at:
-
subject, context, purpose, audience,
thesis, what is NOT said
6)
Interpreting
Statistics
FUNNY à - Three kinds of lies – lies,
damned lies, statistics ß
FUNNY
***********************
If
we don’t, then who will? **********************
-
Are students adequately prepared ?
-
If they are not prepared, then what will
happen to them?
-
What is more important in 10 years –
“Gatsby” or making sense of a ballot initiative
The Art of Teaching
Deep Reading
4 Key Questions when
planning deeper reading lessons:
1)
Without teacher assistance, what will the students take from the reading?
2)
With assistance, what do I want the kids to take from the reading?
3) How
do I bridge the gap between what the kids learn on their own and what I want
them to learn?
4) How do I know if they “got
it”?
EXCELLENT à
AIDS example ß
***********Assessments
should drive the teaching****************
(Backward design)
– students should know “final exam” question
before reading novel
Danger Lurks! :
1) Over teaching the book
2) Student becomes over reliant on the teacher
Begin the year with
lots of help and reduce teacher role in the process gradually so the student is
using strategies more independently
No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.