- In Chapter 4 on pg. 53, the author discusses how first draft reading should be like first draft writing. He quotes: "the first draft is like the down draft- you just get it down. The second draft is the updraft- you fix it up. You try to say what you have to say more accurately." I am by no means disagreeing with this statement. However, in the age of computers and word processing, student don't think like this anymore. They too often sit at computer, type it as they think it, rely on spell-check to notice mistakes, correct them, and turn it in. While I like his metaphor, how do we train students (against everything that modern technology is teaching them) to slow down, re-read, appreciate something as a "first draft reading", and take the time to perfect their understanding?
- On pg. 64, the author refers to "reader's welfare"- students hoping that the teacher will provide the meaning without them having to expend any real effort. In our classroom, we have a severe disadvantage if this is a learning behavior from elementary school teachers, middle school teachers, high school teachers, parents, etc. Students often get "mad" or give-up if they have become accustomed to this. How do we "break" students from feeling the entitlement that meaning should simply be provided or hinted at?
- I'm confused as to the author's series of questions "What does it say? What does it mean? What does it matter?" If I asked students the last one, I don't think they'd understand. Shouldn't it be "WHY does it matter?" or am I wrong?
- I really like all of his points in Chapter 6 about forming groups. His guidelines on gender and ethnic blend seem very meaningful. In a school in California, I can see why this would lend itself to very rich collaboration, but in a homogenous, small-town district like ours, how do we make this as enriching? A large majority of our students have lived here their whole lives, we have very little ethnic variety, and our small school and limited scheduling even makes the gender mixing part tricky. What strategies do we all use to put groups together?
Sunday, April 6, 2014
Questions for Chapters 4-6
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.