Sunday, April 27, 2014

Deeper Reading Chapters 7-10



 Ann Staiger
Chapters 7-10

I particularly enjoyed the last three chapters as they pertained more to my subject area.  These are notes I jotted down as I read.

Leading Students to Meaningful Reflection:    The so what question is key and the strategies he presented seemed to me to provide some really good methods to help students gain that reflection piece.   What does it mean to me?  Is another question we want students to ask (and be able to answer) Making connections using personal experiences and knowledge will help them gain a better understanding.
Reading the World:  This was a great chapter as it provides our students with learning that transcends the classroom and gives them skills for understanding the real world.  Understanding how propaganda influences us all (or reminds us as well) when making decisions.   Good for soc. studies
The Art of Deep Reading:  Knowing your assessment prior to starting the unit is key.  The questions that you ask should reflect the deeper reading level you want the students to be at-less mult choice-NYS tests???

·         The AIDS article – his teaching points about giving students background knowledge first goes contrary to the CORE CURRICULUM points – in that students are not supposed to need any background info and to me shows why that is not an effective means to really teach.
·         All of his ideas –such as the teaching of the AIDS article reinforced the idea that really effective teaching is time consuming and very interactive.  How many teachers are willing to put in this type of time to create these types of lessons?
·         Knowing the assessment before teaching a book or unit is key.  
·         He makes the point that how you teach a book varies from year to year –class to class.  I’ve found this to be true.  It is an ongoing process.
·         “Teaching is not being an information dispenser"
What do I hope my students will take from this book?   Keeps the focus on the student needs, not the teacher’s needs (154)
Mining levels of reflection – for a social studies text, having students understand what the book means in terms of the circle of reflection.   Trying to get them to see how history isn’t just about facts but how it actually impacts them from self, to family, country, etc.  (157)
I thought the Loaded Language section and the pages about advertising was a good idea- all the propaganda techniques for students to be aware of

Developing self sufficient readers is the primary goal but after reading this book, I realize that it takes committed teachers and is a lengthy process.  Question:  How many teachers are willing to take the time to take this on?
Reading political cartoons – weekly one on current issues.  I’ve added the Cagle link to my blog as it pertains to an understanding of the current issues.
Anticipation Guides - 
       Read related story or current event article, role play an issue, music relevant to text, speech
Focus Poems

K_W_L_R charts   I did these with my 8th graders for WWII unit.

The Most Valuable Idea (159) I thought this was a great way to explain connections to the story and real world (ie what does it mean to me?)

I started listing all the ideas he had but realized that would be a large task in itself.  I think if a teacher pulled out some that they thought would specially work with the novels (or texts) they use, it would be very beneficial.  Using all could be overwhelming.

End thoughts:  
Last pages of the book – sub topics:
The Teacher as an Artist and Teaching versus Assigning were both excellent reflections for all teachers to engage in as we prepare our lessons.   

Final page:   His advice to teachers – ask:  What do my students need and when do they need it?

No comments:

Post a Comment

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.